Skip to content
+971 52 2477942
Failure analysis

Swollen or hardened tube: reading fluid incompatibility off the failure

Cut a failed hose open and the tube tells you whether the fluid was wrong. Swollen and soft is one problem, shrunken and brittle is the opposite one, and both mean the hose and the fluid were never suited.

Written by
Ayush Bhatia, Director
Published
Updated
Reading
3 min · 3 sections
Share
A cut length of hydraulic hose held to camera, its inner tube swollen soft and glossy and closing down the bore
A swollen or hardened inner tube is a sign of fluid incompatibility.

At a glance

Key takeaways

  1. Cut the failed hose lengthways. The tube is the evidence and it is only visible from inside.
  2. Swollen, soft or spongy means the fluid is being absorbed into the tube compound.
  3. Hardened, shrunken or cracked means the fluid has extracted the plasticisers that kept the rubber flexible.
  4. Nearly every hydraulic hose we stock has a nitrile (NBR) tube, which suits mineral oil and does not suit everything else.
  5. Where the fluid is the problem, changing hose grade within the same tube compound changes nothing.

Figures verified · Tube compounds and temperature ranges from the product specifications for the grades we stock. Compatibility must be checked against the specific fluid, concentration and temperature.

Most hose diagnosis happens from outside. This one cannot: a tube attacked by the fluid it is carrying can sit inside a cover that looks entirely healthy, and the only way to see it is to cut the hose open along its length.

/01The two opposite failures.

What the tube looks like, and what it means
Tube conditionMechanismTypical cause
Swollen, soft, spongy, oversizedHighlightedFluid absorbed into the compound, swelling itA fluid the tube was not selected for
Hard, brittle, shrunken, crackedPlasticisers extracted, leaving the rubber stiffAggressive solvent, or sustained heat
Tube separated from the reinforcementAdhesion lost, often after swellingAdvanced incompatibility
Tube eroded or thinned, smoothMechanical, not chemical — abrasive fluidContaminated or particulate-laden fluid

/02What our hose is actually made of.

Macro of raised blisters swelling out of a black hydraulic hose cover, one with a pinhole at its crown
Permeation blisters raise the cover from underneath. They are evidence about the fluid, not about the quality of the hose.

Almost every wire-reinforced hydraulic hose in our range has a nitrile tube. It is the standard choice because it suits mineral hydraulic oil, which is what most systems run. The moment the fluid is not mineral oil, that assumption needs checking. Where it fails the check, R14 PTFE hose is chemically inert, and thermoplastic grades such as R8 use a polyamide tube.

Tube compounds across the grades we stock
TubeGradesSuits
Nitrile (NBR)1SN, 2SN, 1SC, 2SC, 4SP, 4SH, R5, R6, R13, R15Mineral hydraulic oil
Polyamide (nylon)R7, R8 thermoplasticHydraulic fluid, tighter routing, lighter weight
PTFEHighlightedR14Chemically inert — the answer where nitrile fails

/03Heat makes everything else worse.

Chemical attack accelerates with temperature. A fluid the tube tolerates at 60 °C can attack it steadily at 100 °C, so a marginal combination that ran for years can start failing when the duty changes — a higher ambient, a hotter summer, a cooler that has silted up.

The grades we stock are rated to 100 °C on most constructions and 121 °C on the spiral and R5 lines, with PTFE at 204 °C. Those are limits for the hose in its intended fluid, not licences to run any fluid up to that temperature.

When the tube compound has to change

Common questions

We changed to a fire-resistant fluid and hoses started failing. Related?
Almost certainly. Phosphate-ester fluids in particular are not compatible with the nitrile tube used in standard hydraulic hose. A fluid change is a hose specification change, and it applies to seals and paint as well.
How do I check compatibility before committing?
Against the tube compound, at the actual concentration and temperature — not against the hose grade. Tell us the fluid and the running temperature and we will tell you which tube suits it.
The tube looks fine but the hose keeps leaking at the fittings.
Check the seals and O-rings in the same fluid. A tube that tolerates a fluid does not guarantee that every elastomer in the circuit does, and the seals usually go first.
Is PTFE always the safe answer?
It is chemically inert and handles far higher temperatures, so it solves most compatibility problems. It is more expensive, less flexible in the small sizes and needs different fittings — worth it where nitrile keeps failing, over-specified where it does not.

What next

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03

    Where we send the replacement

    A failure correctly diagnosed is only worth something if the replacement can reach the machine. Assemblies built to the specification described here are made up and pressure-tested at our Dubai workshop and dispatched with the crimp record and test certificate travelling with them, which counts for more the further the machine sits from a hose shop. Most orders of this kind start as a photograph and a measurement rather than a part number, and that is enough for us to quote from.

    Everything above ships from the same Dubai warehouse. If your destination is not listed, it is almost certainly still one we quote. See every export destination

Changing fluid, or already seeing swelling?

Tell us the fluid, the concentration and the running temperature. We will tell you which tube compound the duty needs — and whether your seals need the same conversation.

Plant-down? Call +971 52 2477942 — 24/7

Keep reading

More on Failure analysis

All articles in this topic
Back to Blog