Skip to content
+971 52 2477942
Failure analysis

Crimp too tight, crimp too loose: what each one leaves behind

A crimp is a measured diameter with a tolerance in tenths of a millimetre. Miss it in either direction and the assembly fails — but it fails differently, and the difference is visible on the failed part.

Written by
Ayush Bhatia, Director
Published
Updated
Reading
4 min · 3 sections
Share
Two crimped hose ends side by side on a steel bench with a vernier caliper set across the flats of one ferrule
Over-crimped and under-crimped ends leave different marks, both measurable with a caliper.

At a glance

Key takeaways

  1. A crimp is a specified diameter, verified with callipers after pressing — not a feel or a machine setting.
  2. Under-crimped assemblies let the hose walk out of the fitting. The failure is early and dramatic.
  3. Over-crimped assemblies cut the reinforcement at the ferrule mouth. The failure is early too, and looks like a hose fault.
  4. A ferrule that fits physically is not evidence it is the right ferrule — the crimp specification is per hose-and-ferrule combination.
  5. Any workshop building assemblies properly can state the crimp diameter it worked to and confirm it was measured.

Figures verified · Workshop practice. Crimp diameters are per hose-and-ferrule combination and come from the fitting manufacturer, not from any general rule.

The crimp is the only part of a hose assembly that is manufactured rather than selected, and it is the only part where the tolerance is measured in tenths of a millimetre. It is also the part nobody can inspect once the assembly is on the machine.

/01What a crimp actually is.

Crimping compresses a steel ferrule onto the hose until the reinforcement is gripped hard enough to hold working pressure and not so hard that the grip damages it. The target is a finished outside diameter, published by the fitting manufacturer for that specific combination of hose construction and ferrule, and reached with a specific die. Our double-skive ferrule for R13 and no-skive ferrule for 1SN and 2SN each have their own crimp diameters for exactly this reason.

Three things therefore have to match: hose, ferrule and die. Change any one and the specified diameter changes with it. This is why a skive fitting on a no-skive hose, or a ferrule that merely fits, produces an assembly whose rating nobody can state.

/02The two directions of error.

What each fault leaves on the failed assembly
FaultEvidenceFailure mode
Under-crimpedHighlightedHose pulled out or moved in the ferrule; tube marks show it walkedBlow-off under pressure, often early and total
Over-crimpedHighlightedWire cut or crushed at the ferrule mouth; sharp failure line at the edgeBurst right at the ferrule edge
Wrong ferrule for the constructionFerrule length or profile does not match the hose reinforcementEither of the above, unpredictably
Not skived where requiredCover trapped under the ferrule instead of removedGrip on cover rather than on wire; pull-out
Insufficient insertion depthShort witness mark; hose not seated to the fitting shoulderPull-out

/03Why "it held on test" is not proof.

A hydraulic hose crimping machine on a bench with its full set of die rings laid out in an arc from largest to smallest
Consistency is what a crimper is really bought for, and consistency lives in the dies as much as in the machine.

A proof test confirms the assembly holds a pressure now. It does not confirm the crimp is within specification, because a marginal crimp holds a static test comfortably and then fails after a few thousand pressure cycles. The test and the crimp measurement answer different questions, and a workshop that does one and not the other is checking the easier thing.

Common questions

Can an over-crimped hose be identified before it fails?
Only by measuring the crimp diameter, which means measuring it at build. Once the assembly is fitted there is no external sign, which is why the measurement has to happen in the workshop rather than being inferred later.
Is a field crimp less reliable than a workshop crimp?
Not inherently — the same specification applies and portable machines are capable of meeting it. What changes is the working conditions and whether the verification actually happens with the machine standing in the sun.
The ferrule fits the hose. Is that enough?
No. Ferrules are specified per hose construction, not per dash size, and several will physically slide onto the same hose. The crimp diameter published for the combination is what makes it the right ferrule.
Can I re-crimp an assembly that pulled out?
No. The ferrule is deformed and the hose end has been damaged by walking out of it. Cut back to sound hose and use a new fitting.

Parts for this job

What next

  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03

    Where we send the replacement

    A failure correctly diagnosed is only worth something if the replacement can reach the machine. Assemblies built to the specification described here are made up and pressure-tested at our Dubai workshop and dispatched with the crimp record and test certificate travelling with them, which counts for more the further the machine sits from a hose shop. Most orders of this kind start as a photograph and a measurement rather than a part number, and that is enough for us to quote from.

    Everything above ships from the same Dubai warehouse. If your destination is not listed, it is almost certainly still one we quote. See every export destination

Assemblies failing at the ferrule?

Ask us what crimp diameter we work to for your combination — we will tell you, and we measure every one after pressing.

Plant-down? Call +971 52 2477942 — 24/7

Keep reading

More on Failure analysis

All articles in this topic
Back to Blog