Skip to content
Heat-transfer tubes

A179 vs A192 vs A210 vs A213: choosing boiler and exchanger tube

Four ASTM standards cover most carbon and alloy steel tube in exchangers, boilers and superheaters. What each is for, how they differ in chemistry and strength, which tests they carry, and how to choose — with the grade tables.

Written by
Ayush Bhatia, Director
Published
Reading
3 min · 4 sections
Share

At a glance

Key takeaways

  1. A179 is cold-drawn low-carbon tube for exchangers and condensers; A192 is the same chemistry made for high-pressure boiler service.
  2. Neither A179 nor A192 has a mandatory minimum tensile: hardness controls them.
  3. A210 is medium-carbon boiler and superheater tube, in Grades A-1 and C, with minimum tensile and yield.
  4. A213 covers ferritic alloy (T11, T22, T91…) and austenitic stainless boiler, superheater and exchanger tube.
  5. Pick by service: the design code, pressure and metal temperature on the data sheet decide.

Figures verified · Chemistry and minimum mechanicals from the ASTM standards as compiled in our approved grade data. Check the current edition for a contract.

Most steel tube in a refinery exchanger, a boiler or an HRSG is ordered to one of four ASTM standards. They look interchangeable on a quick read — same sizes, similar names — but they are written for different duties, and swapping one for another changes what the mill must test and guarantee.

/01The carbon steels.

Carbon steel tube grades (approved grade data; % by weight)
GradeC %Mn %Min tensileMin yieldMax hardness
A1790.06–0.180.27–0.63No requirement (hardness-controlled)—72 HRB
A1920.06–0.180.27–0.63No requirement (hardness-controlled)—137 HB
A210 A-1≤0.27≤0.93415 MPa255 MPa79 HRB / 143 HB
A210 C≤0.350.29–1.06485 MPa275 MPa89 HRB / 179 HB

A179 is the default exchanger and condenser tube and the usual base tube for finned air-cooler bundles. It is cold drawn and heat treated after the final draw so it can be expanded into a tube sheet, and it is tested by flattening, flaring, flange, hardness and hydrostatic tests. A192 has the same carbon and manganese range and adds a silicon limit; it is made for boiler and superheater tubes at high pressure. A210 is medium-carbon tube with real strength minimums: Grade A-1 at 415 MPa tensile and Grade C at 485 MPa, used for boiler, economiser and water-wall tube.

/02The alloy steels under A213.

A213 ferritic alloy grades (approved grade data)
GradeUNSCr %Mo %Min tensileMin yield
T11K115971.00–1.500.44–0.65415 MPa205 MPa
T12K115620.80–1.250.44–0.65415 MPa220 MPa
T22K215901.90–2.600.87–1.13415 MPa205 MPa
T5K415454.00–6.000.45–0.65415 MPa205 MPa
T9K909418.00–10.000.90–1.10415 MPa205 MPa
T91K909018.00–9.500.85–1.05585 MPa415 MPa

Chrome-moly grades raise creep strength and oxidation resistance as the metal temperature rises: T11 and T12 for moderate superheater temperatures, T22 above them, T5 and T9 where sulphidation matters in fired heaters, and T91 for the hottest superheater and reheater sections. T91 is supplied normalised and tempered — never annealed — and its tempering must be controlled in fabrication. A213 also covers austenitic stainless tube, compared in stainless exchanger tube grades.

/03Testing.

Under the general requirements (ASTM A450 for carbon tube, A1016 for alloy and stainless), each tube is hydrostatically tested or given an electric non-destructive test at the mill’s option unless the order says which. Some mills recommend combining ultrasonic and eddy-current testing for A209 and A213. If the project wants both, or 100 % eddy current, write it on the order.

/04Choosing.

  • Shell-and-tube exchanger or condenser, carbon steel: A179.
  • Boiler tube at high pressure, low carbon: A192.
  • Boiler, economiser or water wall needing a strength minimum: A210 A-1 or C.
  • Superheater, reheater or fired-heater coil at high metal temperature: A213 T11, T22, T5, T9 or T91, per the design.

European equivalents (P235GH, P265GH, 16Mo3, 13CrMo4-5, 10CrMo9-10) are in DIN to EN 10216. Cross-references are indicative; we check each against the tender.

Common questions

Can A192 replace A179?
The chemistry is almost the same, but the standards differ in purpose and tests. Substitute only with the purchaser’s or designer’s approval.
What is the minimum tensile strength of A179?
A179 has no mandatory minimum tensile strength; hardness (72 HRB maximum) controls it.
What is the difference between A210 A-1 and C?
Grade C has more carbon and manganese allowed and higher minimums: 485 MPa tensile and 275 MPa yield, against 415 and 255 MPa for A-1.
Is T91 annealed?
No. T91 is normalised and tempered; annealing is not permitted.
Which standard covers alloy boiler tube?
ASTM A213 for ferritic alloy grades such as T11, T22 and T91, with A209 for carbon-molybdenum T1 grades.

Boiler and exchanger tube in the catalogue

Keep reading

More on Heat-transfer tubes

All articles in this topic

Reading a mill test certificate to EN 10204 3.1

3 min read

Finned tube fouling and cleaning in Gulf dust

2 min read

Back to Blog